# Personal injury lawyers call for legal aid means test to look only at a brain-injured child's own resources

> APIL says assessing both parents' finances when a brain-injured child applies for legal aid is unjust, and has asked the Scottish Government to count only the child's resources.

Published 4 November 2026 by The Law Wire. Topic: Justice & legal aid. Canonical: https://lawwire.co.uk/story/apil-legal-aid-means-test-brain-injured-children-unjust

The Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL) has told the Scottish Government that the way legal aid is assessed for brain-injured children is unjust, and wants only the child's own resources counted ([Scottish Legal News](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/legal-aid-system-for-brain-damaged-children-in-scotland-is-unjust)).

## What we know

- **The issue:** under the current rules, both parents' finances are taken into account when deciding whether a child's claim qualifies for legal aid. The cases in question often involve brain injury following negligent hospital treatment at birth.
- **APIL's argument:** Gordon Dalyell, APIL's Scotland representative, says parents' money is largely committed to the child's specialist care and should not be treated as spare. He says NHS Scotland does not provide all the care and treatment these children need, so compensation is needed for equipment and therapies.
- **The proposal:** assess only the child's resources in these applications.
- **Where it was made:** in APIL's response to the Scottish Government's consultation on modernising the legal aid system. Legal aid is used in some personal injury cases where other funding is not available.
- **The cost argument:** Mr Dalyell says that if families cannot recover compensation from those responsible, the state ends up paying for the child's care and living support instead.

## Why it matters

The point now sits with ministers alongside other responses to the legal aid consultation. Firms acting for claimants in birth injury cases, and NHS boards and their advisers on the defence side, will want to watch how the Scottish Government treats it.

## Sources

- [Scottish Legal News — Legal aid system for brain-damaged children in Scotland is 'unjust'](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/legal-aid-system-for-brain-damaged-children-in-scotland-is-unjust)
