# Appeal Court refuses comparative justice sentence appeals in Operation Venetic case

> The Appeal Court of the High Court of Justiciary has refused appeals by David Nisbet and Declan McCuish against extended sentences for conspiracy to murder, rejecting arguments that their sentences were excessive compared with others.

Published 16 November 2026 by The Law Wire. Topic: Courts & cases. Canonical: https://lawwire.co.uk/story/appeal-court-refuses-nisbet-mccuish-comparative-justice-appeals

The Appeal Court of the High Court of Justiciary has refused sentence appeals by David Nisbet and Declan James McCuish. Both men argued that their extended sentences for a conspiracy to murder were excessive when compared with sentences imposed on others, according to the [opinion published by the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service](https://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/media/ktfbbe0h/2026hcjac47-appeals-against-sentence-by-david-nisbet-and-declan-james-mccuish-against-his-majestys-advocate.pdf) and a report by [Scottish Legal News](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/high-court-rejects-comparative-justice-challenges-to-sentences-for-murder-conspiracy).

## What we know

The opinion, [2026] HCJAC 47, is dated 10 November 2026. It was delivered by Lord Beckett, the Lord Justice Clerk, sitting with Lord Matthews and Lord Ericht. Nisbet appeared as a party appellant. McCuish was represented by Mohammed KC, instructed by Paterson Bell for John Kilcoyne and Co. The Crown was represented by Dalziel (Sol Adv) AD.

Both men were sentenced on 27 March 2025 after trial at the High Court in Glasgow. Nisbet received a cumulative extended sentence of 16 years, made up of a 13-year custodial term and a three-year extension. McCuish received 14 years, made up of an 11-year custodial term and a three-year extension.

The court said that "it is rarely straightforward to achieve comparative justice". On Nisbet's comparison with two others, Connell and Haggerty, it stated: "There is no valid comparison to be made." The opinion also discusses the 2023 sentences of Gilmour and Mullen. It notes that those sentences pre-dated *HM Advocate v Fergusson* [2024] HCJAC 22 by almost a year and that each was reduced by one quarter for a guilty plea.

## What others are reporting

[Scottish Legal News](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/high-court-rejects-comparative-justice-challenges-to-sentences-for-murder-conspiracy) reported that both appeals were refused and that the court found no miscarriage of justice. It spells the name of one comparator "Haggarty". It reported that the comparators cited by Nisbet were not valid. Haggarty, sentenced to four years and six months, was not convicted on the same organised-crime charge. Connell, sentenced to six years and nine months, was sentenced under section 28 of the Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010, which carries a lower maximum.

On McCuish, the outlet reported that the court held he remained a significant participant even though Nisbet was slightly more culpable. It said the court found that the other Operation Venetic cases raised no true comparative justice issue. It also listed *Simpkins*, *Armstrong* and *Douglas* among the authorities the court reviewed.

## Background

Scottish Legal News describes Operation Venetic as involving material obtained after French authorities overcame the security of the EncroChat system. The outlet describes *Fergusson* as endorsing a cumulative approach to sentencing for multiple offences: individual sentences are identified and totalled, then reduced where needed for fairness and proportionality. The opinion also cites *Miller v HM Advocate* [2024] HCJAC 3, *Huynh v HM Advocate* [2026] HCJAC 6 and the Scottish Sentencing Council's Principles and purposes of sentencing guideline.

## What to watch

- How [2026] HCJAC 47 is relied on in other sentence appeals that compare co-accused or linked cases.
- How the courts treat sentences imposed before *Fergusson* when they are offered as comparators.
- Further appellate guidance on cumulative sentencing for multiple offences.

For criminal practitioners, the decision underlines how demanding comparative justice arguments are on appeal. The court treated differences in the charge, the statutory basis of the sentence, timing relative to *Fergusson* and discounts for guilty pleas as reasons why apparently lower sentences elsewhere were not true comparators.

As Operation Venetic prosecutions produce a growing body of sentences, the risk of disparity arguments is evident. The opinion suggests that a headline difference in sentence length will rarely be enough on its own. Its analysis of sentences imposed before *Fergusson* is also relevant to practitioners advising on comparisons across that change in approach to cumulative sentencing.

What remains open is how far the court will go in reconciling sentences from different periods and procedural routes within the same investigation. That question may recur as further linked cases reach the Appeal Court.

## Sources

- [Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service — [2026] HCJAC 47](https://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/media/ktfbbe0h/2026hcjac47-appeals-against-sentence-by-david-nisbet-and-declan-james-mccuish-against-his-majestys-advocate.pdf)
- [Scottish Legal News — High Court rejects comparative justice challenges](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/high-court-rejects-comparative-justice-challenges-to-sentences-for-murder-conspiracy)
