# Biffa appeals dismissal of £51.4m deposit return scheme claim against ministers

> Biffa is appealing in the Court of Session after its £51.4m claim over the collapsed deposit return scheme was thrown out in January. The Scottish Government says the new points of law are irrelevant.

Published 19 November 2026 by The Law Wire. Topic: Courts & cases. Canonical: https://lawwire.co.uk/story/biffa-appeals-deposit-return-scheme-claim-dismissal

Waste firm Biffa is back in the Court of Session seeking damages from the Scottish Government over the collapse of Scotland's bottle and can recycling scheme. [BBC News](https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/waste-firm-appeals-over-51m-162532385.html) reported that the company is appealing against the January decision that dismissed its £51.4m claim.

## What we know

According to the BBC, Lord Sandison threw out Biffa's claim in January, describing it as "wishful thinking". Biffa continues to maintain that it was misled by ministers who, it says, owed it a duty of care, and it is now appealing that ruling in the Court of Session.

The BBC reported that the case hinges on a 2022 letter sent by Lorna Slater while she was a government minister.

The Scottish Government has urged the court to dismiss the appeal, the BBC reported, arguing that the new points of law raised by Biffa are "irrelevant".

The court has not yet ruled on the appeal.

## Background

The deposit return scheme would have added a 20p charge to single-use bottles and cans, refunded when the container was returned, the [BBC](https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/waste-firm-appeals-over-51m-162532385.html) reported. Biffa had been contracted as the scheme's main logistics partner.

The scheme was shelved in 2023 amid a dispute between the Scottish and UK governments, according to the BBC. Biffa's claim seeks to recover losses it says it suffered as a result of the scheme's collapse, on the basis of what it says it was told by ministers.

At first instance in the Outer House, Lord Sandison rejected the claim. The appeal tests whether that decision should stand.

## What to watch

- Whether the appeal court accepts that the new points of law raised by Biffa are relevant, or upholds the Scottish Government's position that they are not.
- How the court approaches Biffa's argument that ministers owed it a duty of care in relation to the 2022 letter.
- The timing of a written opinion from the appeal court, which will be published by the Scottish courts.
- Any further steps, including a possible appeal to the UK Supreme Court, once the Court of Session has ruled.

The Biffa litigation is one of the more closely watched commercial fallouts from the deposit return scheme's collapse, and the appeal puts squarely in issue how far a private contractor can rely on ministerial communications when committing to a government-led project. Lord Sandison's "wishful thinking" characterisation, as reported by the BBC, set a high bar for the company, and ministers are resisting the appeal on the basis that Biffa's new legal arguments are irrelevant.

For Scottish firms advising suppliers to public bodies, and for in-house teams in the public sector, the outcome may shape how assurances from ministers are framed and relied upon in future large-scale schemes. Any appellate guidance on whether, and when, ministers owe a duty of care to commercial partners would be of wider interest across public and commercial practice. Until the appeal court issues its opinion, the January decision stands, and the reasoning of both courts will matter more than the headline sum.

## Sources

- [BBC News (via Yahoo News)](https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/waste-firm-appeals-over-51m-162532385.html)
- [bbc.co.uk](https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2053ezn2x8o)
- [britbrief.co.uk](https://britbrief.co.uk/politics/devolved/biffa-appeals-50m-drs-ruling-over-legal-error.html)
