# Scottish Government drops right to a healthy environment from planned Human Rights Bill

> The right, recommended in 2021 and included in the 2023 consultation, will not be in the bill due next year. More than 100 civil society organisations had urged ministers to keep it.

Published 29 October 2026 by The Law Wire. Topic: Regulation & policy. Canonical: https://lawwire.co.uk/story/human-rights-bill-right-to-healthy-environment-dropped

The Scottish Government has left the right to a healthy environment out of its forthcoming Human Rights Bill, which is due to be introduced next year ([Scottish Legal News](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/scottish-government-drops-right-to-healthy-environment-from-human-rights-bill)).

## What we know

- **History:** the National Taskforce for Human Rights Leadership recommended the right in 2021, and it was included in the government's 2023 consultation on the bill. Legal and academic experts had worked with the government on the proposal for nine years.
- **Opposition:** more than 100 civil society organisations signed an open letter the week before urging ministers to keep it.
- **The campaigners' case:** they argue the right could shape budget and strategic decisions on food and energy insecurity, health inequalities, climate change and biodiversity loss, and support Scotland's net zero and biodiversity targets.

## What they said

Shivali Fifield, chief officer of the Environmental Rights Centre for Scotland, said: "It is unbelievable that this decision has been made with no prior consultation with civil society stakeholders." Charlie McMillan, director of Human Rights Consortium Scotland, said a healthy environment is "fundamental to the enjoyment of human rights."

## Who it affects

Public bodies, environmental and human rights organisations, and public law and environmental practitioners who advise on challenges to public decisions. The bill's final shape will be clearer once it is introduced.

## Sources

- [Scottish Legal News — Scottish government drops right to healthy environment from bill](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/scottish-government-drops-right-to-healthy-environment-from-human-rights-bill)
