# Inner House rules Information Commissioner erred in ordering release of Hamilton inquiry evidence over jigsaw identification risk

> The First Division allowed the Scottish Ministers' appeals, holding that disclosure creating a real risk of identifying complainers protected by reporting restrictions would breach those orders. The requests go back to the Commissioner.

Published 30 October 2026 by The Law Wire. Topic: Courts & cases. Canonical: https://lawwire.co.uk/story/inner-house-allows-ministers-foi-appeals-hamilton-inquiry-jigsaw-identification

The First Division of the Court of Session has allowed appeals by the Scottish Ministers against decisions of the Scottish Information Commissioner ordering release of evidence used by the Hamilton inquiry, and sent the requests back to the Commissioner ([Judiciary of Scotland summary](https://judiciary.scot/home/sentences-judgments/judgments/2026/10/30/the-scottish-ministers-v-the-scottish-information-commissioner)). The Lord President, Lord Pentland, delivered the [opinion of the court](https://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/media/bb2jf3g1/2026csih46-appeals-by-scottish-ministers-against-the-information-commissioner.pdf) on 30 October after a hearing on 22 September.

## The background

The Hamilton inquiry examined whether former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon breached the Ministerial Code in handling complaints about Alex Salmond. Freedom of information requests sought evidence used by that inquiry. The Ministers relied on section 26(c) of the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002, which exempts information whose disclosure would be a contempt of court. They argued release could allow "jigsaw identification" of complainers protected by reporting restrictions.

The Commissioner held that the exemption applies only where disclosure would actually be a contempt, not where there is merely a risk. He considered jigsaw identification but concluded the complainers would not be identified.

## The decision

The court held that the Commissioner erred in law. Relying on Murray v HM Advocate, which was first raised on appeal, it said a breach of reporting restrictions occurs if disclosure creates a real or substantial risk of identification. The Commissioner had accepted that release could lead to assumptions about the complainers' identities. The court said that would heighten the danger of identification and conflict with the purpose of the orders: protecting the complainers' dignity, privacy and safety. That was a material misdirection in law.

## Why it matters

Public bodies handling requests that touch on material covered by reporting restrictions now have appellate guidance that the test is real risk of identification, not certainty. The Judiciary of Scotland notes its summary is not authoritative; the opinion is.

## Sources

- [Judiciary of Scotland — Judgment summary: The Scottish Ministers against The Scottish Information Commissioner](https://judiciary.scot/home/sentences-judgments/judgments/2026/10/30/the-scottish-ministers-v-the-scottish-information-commissioner)
- [Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service — Opinion of the court](https://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/media/bb2jf3g1/2026csih46-appeals-by-scottish-ministers-against-the-information-commissioner.pdf)
