# Aberdeen hotel cladding claim survives prescription challenge in the Court of Session

> Lord Richardson refused motions by Galliford Try, BDP and Kingspan to dismiss a tenant's cladding claim over the Leonardo Inn at Union Square as time-barred. The case goes to proof before answer on concealment under section 6(4).

Published 28 October 2026 by The Law Wire. Topic: Courts & cases. Canonical: https://lawwire.co.uk/story/leonardo-hotel-aberdeen-cladding-claim-survives-prescription-challenge

A hotel tenant's claim for the cost of replacing allegedly defective cladding at the Leonardo Inn, part of the Union Square development in Aberdeen, will go to proof after the Court of Session refused to throw it out as time-barred ([Scottish Legal News](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/outer-house-allows-leonardo-hotel-cladding-action-to-proceed-despite-prescription-challenges)).

## What we know

- **The case:** Leonardo Hotel Management (UK) Ltd v Galliford Try Building 2014 Ltd and others, [2026] CSOH 103, decided by Lord Richardson in the Outer House.
- **The parties:** Leonardo, the tenant, sued the successor to the design and build contractor and the architect, Building Design Partnership, both of which had granted it collateral warranties. BDP then brought in Kingspan Insulation, maker of the Kooltherm K15 insulation.
- **The timeline:** practical completion of the hotel was in February 2009, Leonardo took its lease in December 2009 and the action was raised in February 2021.
- **Discoverability failed:** the judge held Leonardo's arguments under section 11(3) of the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973 irrelevant, because its loss was locked in when it took on the lease's repairing obligation. Both warranties also let the defenders rely on prescription defences available under the original contracts.
- **Concealment survived:** Leonardo had pled enough under section 6(4) that physical concealment of defects, and failures to identify or report them, induced it and its landlord not to claim. The judge found "no support in the language of the provision" for a further restriction on the kind of conduct that counts.
- **The Kingspan claim:** BDP's claim against Kingspan also survives; the court said a 2017 report was not clear enough to decide actual knowledge at debate.
- **Outcome:** proof before answer, except on the averments held irrelevant ([Scottish Construction Now](https://www.scottishconstructionnow.com/articles/aberdeen-hotel-cladding-claim-to-progress-as-judge-rejects-prescription-challenge)).

## Who acted

Morton Fraser MacRoberts instructed counsel for Leonardo; Clyde & Co for Galliford Try; Kennedys for BDP; and Balfour and Manson for Kingspan, which was represented by the Dean of Faculty, Roddy Dunlop KC.

For construction and real estate litigators, the useful points are that a tenant's loss under a repairing lease can be fixed at the date of entry, and that section 6(4) concealment arguments can still keep older cladding claims alive past debate. Brodies has published a [commentary on the decision](https://brodies.com/insights/construction-and-engineering/undercover-cladding-what-does-it-mean-for-prescription/).

## Sources

- [Scottish Legal News — Outer House allows Leonardo Hotel cladding action to proceed despite prescription challenges](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/outer-house-allows-leonardo-hotel-cladding-action-to-proceed-despite-prescription-challenges)
- [Scottish Construction Now — Aberdeen hotel cladding claim to progress as judge rejects prescription challenge](https://www.scottishconstructionnow.com/articles/aberdeen-hotel-cladding-claim-to-progress-as-judge-rejects-prescription-challenge)
- [Brodies — Undercover cladding: what does it mean for prescription?](https://brodies.com/insights/construction-and-engineering/undercover-cladding-what-does-it-mean-for-prescription/)
