# NHS Tayside fined £75,250 after dementia patient's death at Murray Royal Hospital

> Tayside Health Board has been fined £75,250 at Perth Sheriff Court after admitting a health and safety breach. A high-risk dementia patient died after a fall, and the alarms meant to alert staff were not working.

Published 17 November 2026 by The Law Wire. Topic: Courts & cases. Canonical: https://lawwire.co.uk/story/nhs-tayside-fined-dementia-patient-death-murray-royal

Tayside Health Board has been fined £75,250 after pleading guilty to a breach of health and safety regulations at Perth Sheriff Court on 16 November 2026. The case followed the death of an 82-year-old dementia patient at Murray Royal Hospital in Perth, [Scottish Legal News reported](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/nhs-tayside-fined-following-death-of-vulnerable-patient).

## What we know

According to Scottish Legal News, the patient was Andrea Imrie. She was being cared for in a dementia assessment ward at the hospital. She had been assessed as at high risk of falls because of her dementia and previous falls. Her care plan required both a bed pad alarm and a room movement sensor to be in place overnight.

In the early hours of 6 January 2024, staff found Ms Imrie out of bed. The room sensor alarm had not gone off. Moments later, staff heard her fall and found her on the floor with a head injury. She died on 13 January 2024.

A Health and Safety Executive investigation found three problems:

- the bed pad alarm had been removed because of equipment shortages;
- a damaged room movement sensor had failed to alert staff;
- the system for checking alarms was deficient.

Debbie Carroll, who leads on health and safety investigations for the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS), said the care plan had "identified clear measures" but that these "were not fully in place". She said organisations responsible for vulnerable people must ensure risk controls are "available, maintained and working effectively at all times". She added that no prosecution can undo the consequences of what happened.

## What others are reporting

[STV News](https://news.stv.tv/north/nhs-tayside-fined-75000-after-alarm-failures-led-to-death-of-high-risk-dementia-patient) also covered the case. It reported the same HSE findings and the same comments from COPFS. It confirmed that the board entered its plea on Monday and that the fine was £75,250. Neither outlet reported any statement from the health board or the family, or any remarks by the sheriff.

## Background

Scottish Legal News reported that after the incident the board took two steps on the ward:

- it increased the number of bed pad alarms;
- it introduced revised procedures for checking and recording alarms and sensors at bedtime.

The published reports do not name the specific statutory provision under which the board was charged.

## What to watch

- Whether COPFS publishes its own statement on the case, including details of the charge.
- Any response from NHS Tayside on the ward changes described in coverage.
- Further prosecutions of health boards arising from HSE investigations into patient safety equipment and checking systems.

The case is a reminder that a sound risk assessment does not protect an organisation if the controls it identifies are not actually in place. Here the care plan set out the right measures. According to the HSE findings reported, the failures were practical ones: an alarm removed because of equipment shortages, a damaged sensor, and weak checking of whether alarms worked.

COPFS framed the duty as making sure controls are available, maintained and working at all times. That framing is likely to interest those advising health boards, care providers and other organisations looking after vulnerable people, particularly where resources are stretched.

Several questions remain open from the published coverage. It does not identify the provision charged. It does not record any sentencing remarks, so it is unclear how the guilty plea or the board's remedial steps were weighed. Nor does it include any comment from the board.

## Sources

- [Scottish Legal News](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/nhs-tayside-fined-following-death-of-vulnerable-patient)
- [STV News](https://news.stv.tv/north/nhs-tayside-fined-75000-after-alarm-failures-led-to-death-of-high-risk-dementia-patient)
