Carmont derailment inquiry finds reasonable precautions might have prevented three deaths
Sheriff Lesley Johnston found a drain not built to its design, and missing as-built records, contributed to the 2020 derailment near Stonehaven. She made no recommendations, saying industry changes have addressed the issues.
By The Law Wire · Edited by David Bain

The fatal accident inquiry into the Carmont derailment has found that reasonable precautions might have prevented the deaths of three men, and that a defect in a system of working contributed to the accident (Scottish Legal News). Sheriff Lesley Johnston's determination was reported on 4 November.
What happened
On 12 August 2020 the Aberdeen to Glasgow service was stopped after a landslip following heavy rain and turned back towards Stonehaven. After restarting, it struck debris washed from a drain onto the line at about 73mph and derailed between Stonehaven and Carmont signal boxes. Driver Brett McCullough, conductor Donald Dinnie and passenger Christopher Stuchbury died. Six other passengers were injured.
The findings
- Carillion Construction Limited built a new drain, designed by Ove Arup and Partners, but not to the design. A bund that was not in the design was a significant cause of the washout.
- Carillion did not prepare or give Network Rail "as built" drawings.
- Network Rail did not know the drain had not been built as designed, and did not make sure its own standards on those drawings and a health and safety file were followed.
No new recommendations
The Rail Accident Investigation Branch had made 20 recommendations. The sheriff found most had been implemented and the rest were in progress, and identified no further precautions. Network Rail pleaded guilty in 2023 to a breach of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 and was fined £6.7 million.
Laura Buchan, legal director at the Crown Office, said FAIs "can help families understand what happened" (Scottish Legal News).
Why it matters
The findings turn on construction records and asset owners' assurance over contractors' work, points relevant to infrastructure owners, contractors and their insurers well beyond rail.
Sources
- 1Scottish Legal News — Carmont derailment inquiry finds reasonable precautions might have prevented deaths scottishlegal.com ↗
- 2Scottish Legal News — COPFS highlight importance of Fatal Accident Inquiries following Carmont determination scottishlegal.com ↗
Summarised in our own words. Spotted an error? Tell us — we correct visibly.
Read next
More courts →
CourtsAppeal Court refuses comparative justice sentence appeals in Operation Venetic case
The Appeal Court of the High Court of Justiciary has refused appeals by David Nisbet and Declan McCuish against extended sentences for conspiracy to murder, rejecting arguments that their sentences were excessive compared with others.
CourtsScottish Six Days Trial organisers negligent over marshal collision, Court of Session rules; rider awarded £380,000
Lady Drummond found Edinburgh and District Motor Club negligent for failing to manage the foreseeable risk of marshals riding against the direction of the 2022 event. The injured competitor was awarded £380,000.
CourtsAddleshaw Goddard prepares group proceedings over McClure Solicitors' family protection trusts
Former clients of McClure Solicitors, which went into administration in 2021, are being invited to register for a proposed Scottish group action over advice given when family protection trusts were sold.
The Roll · Free
Scottish law in two minutes, every weekday.
Sourced, independent, no spin. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy notice.

