Holyrood finance committee warns of a record £720m income tax reconciliation ahead of the 3 December Scottish Budget
The Finance and Public Administration Committee's pre-budget report says 2027-28 will be particularly difficult for the Scottish Government's finances. It asks ministers to update their tax strategy so that new taxes are not brought in one at a time.
By The Law Wire · Edited by David Bain

The Scottish Parliament's Finance and Public Administration Committee published its pre-budget report on 3 November. It warns that the Scottish Government faces a record negative income tax reconciliation of £720 million in 2027-28 (committee report). The report is based on evidence taken before the UK Budget of 28 October. The Scottish Budget for 2027-28 is due on 3 December.
Key findings
- Reconciliation: the £720 million adjustment is the first to exceed the borrowing limit for forecast error. It puts more pressure on day-to-day spending.
- Funding gap: the Medium-Term Financial Strategy projects gaps of £2.624 billion in resource and £2.146 billion in capital by 2029-30.
- Defence: the UK Government's defence prioritisation reduces Scotland's capital funding by £87 million in 2027-28.
- Tax strategy: the committee asks ministers to update their tax strategy and take a coordinated approach to raising revenue, instead of introducing new taxes in isolation. It wants behavioural-response data, including HMRC's analysis of 2023-24, to inform future tax policy.
- Higher rate threshold: the Cabinet Secretary told the committee that raising Scotland's higher-rate threshold to England's level would cost over £800 million in 2026-27.
- Council tax: witnesses widely called for reform.
Why the 3 December Budget matters to advisers
The UK Budget left several decisions to Holyrood. These include whether Scotland follows the higher UK property income tax rates from April 2027. Income tax, Land and Buildings Transaction Tax and council tax could all change in the Scottish Budget, while IHT, CGT and VAT are reserved (MFMac). MFMac notes that the Scottish Government already plans two new council tax bands, for homes over £1m and £2m, from April 2028.
Sources
- 1Scottish Parliament Finance and Public Administration Committee — Pre-budget 2027-28 report parliament.scot ↗
- 2MFMac — Autumn Budget 2026 mfmac.com ↗
Summarised in our own words. Spotted an error? Tell us — we correct visibly.
Read next
More regulation →
RegulationScottish Government to reform section 53 implied enforcement rights for real burdens
An analysis of responses on the Scottish Law Commission's proposals to replace sections 52 and 53 of the Title Conditions (Scotland) Act 2003 finds broad support. Ministers say they will legislate at a suitable opportunity.
RegulationScottish Government opens local governance reform questionnaire; responses close 11 December
Part of a three-month engagement with councils, COSLA and unions on reshaping local governance. Ministers say any changes would raise workforce, assets and service-delivery questions.
RegulationWater regulator caps Scottish Water charge rises at CPI plus 2.5% for 2027–33
The Water Industry Commission for Scotland's Final Determination allows about £7.9 billion of investment over six years, with average bills rising about £16 a year before inflation. New charges take effect from April 2027.
The Roll · Free
Scottish law in two minutes, every weekday.
Sourced, independent, no spin. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy notice.

