Law Society tells MPs any reform of the Lord Advocate's dual role must be evidence-led
Michael Clancy gave evidence to the Scottish Affairs Committee on 4 November. The Society has not taken a position on splitting the prosecution and government adviser roles while Lord Boyd's review runs.
By The Law Wire · Edited by David Bain

The Law Society of Scotland has told MPs that any change to the roles of the Lord Advocate and Solicitor General should rest on evidence and wide consultation. Michael Clancy, the Society's director of law reform, gave oral evidence to the Scottish Affairs Committee on 4 November as part of its inquiry into the Lord Advocate's dual role (Scottish Legal News).
What the Society said
- No position yet on separating the Lord Advocate's roles as head of prosecutions and chief legal adviser to the Scottish Government. The Society is waiting for the Scottish Government's review of the law officer roles, led by Lord Boyd of Duncansby.
- Keep going: it urged the committee to continue its inquiry, saying the evidence gathered could help Lord Boyd.
- Complexity: the Lord Advocate is referred to around 900 times in legislation, which the Society says shows how complex any reform would be.
- Recusal: Mr Clancy suggested putting the mechanism for the Lord Advocate stepping back from certain prosecutions on a statutory footing, with clear definitions, including of who counts as a "politician".
Mr Clancy said the issue should be "examined with care", and called for "proper evidence" on academic, professional and public views. The Society published its written evidence the week before, and the hearing recording is online.
Background
The Society called in summer 2026 for a public consultation on reform, noting that the Scottish Government had committed to one in its 2021 manifesto.
Who it affects
The Crown Office, the Scottish Government and criminal practitioners, for whom the structure of the prosecution service and its independence from government are central.
Sources
- 1Scottish Legal News — Law Society of Scotland addresses MPs in lord advocate inquiry scottishlegal.com ↗
- 2UK Parliament — Law Society of Scotland written evidence committees.parliament.uk ↗
- 3Parliamentlive.tv — Scottish Affairs Committee hearing parliamentlive.tv ↗
Summarised in our own words. Spotted an error? Tell us — we correct visibly.
Read next
More regulation →
RegulationScottish Government to reform section 53 implied enforcement rights for real burdens
An analysis of responses on the Scottish Law Commission's proposals to replace sections 52 and 53 of the Title Conditions (Scotland) Act 2003 finds broad support. Ministers say they will legislate at a suitable opportunity.
RegulationScottish Government opens local governance reform questionnaire; responses close 11 December
Part of a three-month engagement with councils, COSLA and unions on reshaping local governance. Ministers say any changes would raise workforce, assets and service-delivery questions.
RegulationWater regulator caps Scottish Water charge rises at CPI plus 2.5% for 2027–33
The Water Industry Commission for Scotland's Final Determination allows about £7.9 billion of investment over six years, with average bills rising about £16 a year before inflation. New charges take effect from April 2027.
The Roll · Free
Scottish law in two minutes, every weekday.
Sourced, independent, no spin. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy notice.

