Justice Secretary rejects independent chairs for all police gross misconduct hearings
Neil Gray tells Holyrood's justice committee that independently chaired hearings for every officer would not be proportionate, despite police staff associations' 'two-tier' warning.
By The Law Wire · Edited by David Bain

Justice Secretary Neil Gray has ruled out independently chaired gross misconduct hearings for police officers below senior rank, in a letter to Holyrood's justice committee reported by The Scotsman on 17 November.
What we know
- The ask: the Scottish Police Federation and the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents want all gross misconduct hearings to have an independent chair, warning of a "two-tier" system compared with senior officers.
- The current plan: regulations updating police misconduct processes, which MSPs will consider, would let legally qualified chairs oversee gross misconduct cases for senior officers. Extending that to all ranks would likely need new primary legislation, the paper reported.
- The Government's reasons: Mr Gray said responsibility for standards and for disciplinary outcomes should stay aligned with the Chief Constable. He said a model of independently chaired panels for every case, against 424 initial assessments in 2025, would need substantial extra money, administration and legal resource, and a much larger role for a body such as the Police Investigations and Review Commissioner. He said it would not be proportionate or help cases resolve on time.
- The numbers: citing the Scottish Police Authority's latest annual report, The Scotsman said 34 gross misconduct hearings took place in 2024-25, with eight officers dismissed, up from 18 hearings the year before.
Who it affects
Lawyers who act for officers, the staff associations or Police Scotland in conduct proceedings, and those following the misconduct regulations through Holyrood.
Sources
- 1The Scotsman — SNP rules out independent police gross misconduct hearings for officers despite 'two-tier' warning scotsman.com ↗
Summarised in our own words. Spotted an error? Tell us — we correct visibly.
Read next
More regulation →
RegulationHolyrood Bill would add council tax bands for homes worth over £1m and £2m
The Scottish Government has introduced a Bill creating two new council tax bands for the most valuable homes, alongside changes to cognitive impairment exemptions and new local discount powers for councils.
RegulationMPs call for 'NHS 111'-style national legal service for England and Wales
The Commons Justice Committee wants a national legal service, ring-fenced funding, a new regulatory settlement and legislation to reverse PACCAR, citing unmet legal need and supervision weaknesses after firm failures.
RegulationLaw Society names seven new Regulatory Committee members ahead of 2025 Act reforms
Five solicitors and two lay members join the Law Society of Scotland's Regulatory Committee in January 2027, the last appointments its council will make before the committee takes over under the 2025 Act.
The Roll · Free
Scottish law in two minutes, every weekday.
Sourced, independent, no spin. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy notice.

