Skip to content
Friday, 20 November 2026Get the daily brief →

Strasbourg court bars Romanian lawyer for two years over AI-fabricated citations

The European Court of Human Rights has excluded a Romanian lawyer from representing applicants for two years after finding her AI-drafted submissions cited non-existent cases and invented passages in real judgments.

By The Law Wire · Edited by David Bain

Abstract illustration: circuit lines leading to a central gold chip.
Illustration: AI-generated for The Law Wire
Original sourceScottish Legal Newsscottishlegal.comRead ↗

The European Court of Human Rights has barred a Romanian lawyer from representing applicants before it for two years. A chamber of the court found that her submissions, drafted with artificial intelligence tools, cited cases that do not exist and attributed invented paragraphs to genuine judgments. Scottish Legal News reported that the court's president approved the exclusion on 13 November under Rule 44D of the Rules of Court.

What we know

According to Scottish Legal News, the chamber found that the lawyer's submissions:

  • cited non-existent cases;
  • included invented paragraphs said to come from genuine judgments and decisions;
  • used relevant case law inaccurately, or in ways that contradicted her own arguments.

The lawyer acknowledged using AI tools. She described the problems as "inaccuracies" and "citation errors" and admitted she had not checked all the citations sufficiently. The chamber rejected that framing. It found a repeated pattern of substantive errors, not isolated mistakes, and found that some references had not been checked at all.

The chamber said lawyers must verify AI-generated references and arguments against authoritative sources such as HUDOC, the court's case-law database. It said the errors forced the court to spend considerable time verifying the submissions and dealing with proceedings over her conduct, and that this prejudiced the administration of justice. The chamber proposed the two-year exclusion and the president approved it.

The decision applies only to this lawyer. It does not affect the second representative in the case. The court said her right to represent applicants could be restored under its rules. Scottish Legal News did not name her.

What others are reporting

Anadolu Agency attributed the news to the court's registry. It said the ban stops her representing or assisting litigants before the court. It quoted the chamber as finding "a pattern of numerous, repeated, substantive errors" and as saying she had fallen short of her professional and ethical duties. On some references, it quoted the chamber as finding that "no checks whatsoever had been carried out." It also reported that some of the rulings she cited were irrelevant or directly contradicted the arguments they were meant to support.

Background

The court's own reasoning, as reported, frames the problem in two ways. The first is professional duty: a representative must check citations against authoritative sources. The second is cost to the court: staff time is spent verifying submissions that should have been reliable. The sanction targets the individual representative rather than the case. Co-counsel were left unaffected, and the court indicated a route back to representation.

What to watch

  • Whether the court publishes the chamber's decision or a fuller press release setting out the reasoning and the Rule 44D procedure.
  • How, and on what conditions, the lawyer's right to represent applicants could be restored.
  • Whether the court issues wider guidance on AI use in submissions, given its emphasis on checking against HUDOC.

Sources

  1. 1Scottish Legal News scottishlegal.com ↗
  2. 2Anadolu Agency aa.com.tr ↗

Summarised in our own words. Spotted an error? Tell us — we correct visibly.

The Roll · Free

Scottish law in two minutes, every weekday.

Sourced, independent, no spin. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy notice.