Skip to content
Friday, 20 November 2026Get the daily brief →

Insurer entitled to refuse Aberdeen restaurant fire claim over unattended grill, Outer House rules

Lord Lake has granted absolvitor to Intact Insurance after finding a restaurant operator breached a clause requiring cooking equipment to be attended, and that section 11 of the Insurance Act 2015 did not save the claim.

By The Law Wire · Edited by David Bain

Abstract illustration: an open volume with a gold bookmark ribbon.
Illustration: AI-generated for The Law Wire
Original sourceScottish Courts and Tribunals Service — [2026] CSOH 110 opinionscotcourts.gov.ukRead ↗

An insurer was entitled to deny liability for a fire that badly damaged an Aberdeen restaurant because the insured did not comply with a policy condition requiring cooking equipment to be attended while its heat source was operating, the Outer House of the Court of Session has held. In P B Development Company Ltd v Intact Insurance UK Ltd [2026] CSOH 110, Lord Lake granted decree of absolvitor in favour of the defender.

What we know

According to the opinion, dated 11 November 2026, the pursuer owned and operated Vovem Meat & Liquor in Aberdeen and took out insurance with the defender, formerly Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Limited, in March 2024, covering fire among other perils. On 26 September 2024 a fire arising from an "ox grill", a stainless-steel appliance for burning solid fuel to chargrill food, caused extensive damage.

The pursuer argued that the grill being unattended had not increased the risk of the fire. Lord Lake concluded that the fire started under the canopy rather than in the duct, and found it likely that someone in attendance who saw it early would have taken action that might have prevented its spread into the duct. He held that the pursuer had not established that leaving the grill unattended while lit "could not" increase the risk of the fire. He also found that the Kitchen Equipment clause was a condition precedent. He sustained the defender's second, third and fourth pleas-in-law and repelled the pursuer's pleas.

The pursuer was represented by Murray KC, instructed by Ledingham Chalmers LLP; the defender by the Dean of Faculty KC and Breen, instructed by DAC Beachcroft Claims Scotland LLP.

What others are reporting

Scottish Legal News reported that the clause carried a bold warning that non-compliance would mean no property damage or business interruption payment, and that Lord Lake held it did not need to be labelled a condition precedent. It reported that he rejected expert evidence on the meaning of "attended", interpretation being a matter of law, and held that a person need not stand in front of the grill but that being merely nearby was not enough: they had to be in a position to "look after or tend to" it. According to SLN, CCTV showed the chef leaving the kitchen for about 2 minutes 45 seconds, with periods when nobody was in a position to tend the grill. SLN also reported a near-miss the previous day and that quantum had been reserved.

The Press and Journal reported that the restaurant has since been renovated and reopened, and that company accounts showed a £409,000 impairment charge linked to the fire damage.

Background

Section 11 of the Insurance Act 2015, as quoted by SLN, prevents an insurer relying on non-compliance with certain terms if the insured shows the breach "could not have increased the risk of the loss which actually occurred in the circumstances in which it occurred". SLN reported that Lord Lake noted there was little authority on section 11(3) and illustrated it with an example of inadequate locks and a fire caused by faulty wiring.

What to watch

  • Whether a reclaiming motion is lodged in the Inner House.
  • Further judicial treatment of section 11(3), on which the court noted limited authority.
  • How insurers and commercial policyholders approach "unattended" equipment wording following the court's interpretation.

Sources

  1. 1Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service — [2026] CSOH 110 opinion scotcourts.gov.uk ↗
  2. 2Scottish Legal News — Outer House rules Aberdeen restaurant insurer entitled to reject fire claim scottishlegal.com ↗

Summarised in our own words. Spotted an error? Tell us — we correct visibly.

The Roll · Free

Scottish law in two minutes, every weekday.

Sourced, independent, no spin. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy notice.